A dental practice partnership works well until someone wants out, gets sick, gets divorced, or stops pulling their weight. The buy-in negotiation is the only time all owners are motivated to write fair rules, because nobody yet knows which one of them will need them.
Last updated: November 2026
Key Takeaways
- Settle the exit terms during the buy-in. Every later attempt is a negotiation between people who now have opposed interests.
- A buy-sell agreement that says value will be “as agreed by the parties” provides no mechanism at exactly the moment the parties cannot agree.
- A general partnership makes each partner jointly and severally liable for the partnership’s obligations. Practices with co-owners should be in an entity that limits that.
- Since May 2026 you cannot restrain a departing dentist with a non-compete unless they receive value related to a sale, which makes the buyout structure itself the protective mechanism.
- Fund the buy-sell. An unfunded obligation to purchase a deceased owner’s interest is a promise the survivors may not be able to keep.
The three ways a dental practice partnership is formed
The mechanics differ and so do the tax consequences, so name the structure early.
| Structure | How it works | Main consideration |
|---|---|---|
| Purchase of an existing interest | The incoming dentist buys part of the current owner’s interest, and the money goes to the owner | Valuation, and how the buyer finances it |
| Issuance of a new interest | The practice issues new equity and the money goes into the practice | Dilution of the existing owner, and what the capital is for |
| Earned or staged buy-in | Interest vests over time against production or tenure | Tax treatment, and what happens if the associate leaves partway |
A staged buy-in is common because it lets both sides test the relationship. It also creates the most drafting work, because you have to answer what happens at every point along the path rather than only at the end.
The entity behind a dental practice partnership matters more than people expect
Utah permits a dentist to practice as a partner in a lawfully organized partnership under Utah Code 58-69-804(1)(c), but permitted is not the same as advisable.
In a general partnership, Utah Code 16-18-306 makes all partners liable jointly and severally for the debts, obligations, and other liabilities of the partnership. A person who becomes a partner is not personally liable for obligations incurred before they joined, and a limited liability partnership changes the analysis, but the default rule is exposure.
Most multi-owner dental practices are better served by a limited liability company. Utah Code 16-20-304 makes a company’s debts solely the company’s, and provides that failure to observe formalities is not a ground for imposing liability on a member or manager.
If the practice is a professional corporation, remember that Section 16-11-7 voids shares issued to a person not licensed in the same profession, and Section 16-11-13 requires a buyback within 90 days if an owner becomes disqualified. Those rules interact directly with a buy-sell agreement and should be drafted together rather than in separate documents that contradict each other.
What the buy-sell agreement has to decide
This is the document that governs the relationship on its worst day. It should answer each of the following in a way a stranger could apply without asking anyone what was meant.
- Triggering events. Death, disability, retirement, voluntary withdrawal, termination for cause, loss of license, bankruptcy, and divorce.
- Who buys. The practice, the remaining owners, or an option in a stated order.
- Valuation method. A formula, an appraisal process, or a stated value updated annually. Name the method and a tie-breaker.
- Payment terms. Lump sum or installments, interest rate, security, and what happens on default.
- Funding. Life insurance and disability insurance sized to the obligation.
- Restrictions after exit. What the departing owner may and may not do, drafted against the current statute.
- Records and patient communication. Who notifies patients, and how.
The valuation clause is the one that most often fails. An agreement that says value will be agreed by the parties, or determined by the practice’s accountant without saying how, converts a mechanical process into a dispute. Name a method, name who applies it, and name what happens if the two sides get different numbers.
Restrictive covenants no longer do the work
Practices used to protect themselves against a departing co-owner with a covenant in the operating agreement. Utah narrowed that considerably.
Utah Code 34-51-201(1)(b) voids a healthcare non-compete agreement entered into on or after May 6, 2026, and Section 34-51-102(5)(a)(xii) makes a dentist a healthcare worker. Section 34-51-203 voids a nonsolicitation term that would stop a departing dentist from telling patients where they are going.
The exception in Section 34-51-202(1)(b) preserves a covenant related to or arising out of the sale of a business where the restricted individual receives value related to the sale. A buyout of a co-owner’s interest is a considerably better fit for that exception than an ordinary employment covenant, because the departing owner is genuinely receiving sale value. That is a drafting opportunity, and it argues for structuring the exit as a purchase of the interest with the covenant tied to it explicitly.
What has not changed is that ordinary nonsolicitation of staff, and nondisclosure and confidentiality obligations, sit outside the definition of a non-compete agreement entirely.
Governing a dental practice partnership while everyone is still getting along
Two owners with equal interests and no tie-breaker is the most common deadlock structure in professional practices, and it is entirely avoidable.
Utah Code 16-20-107 sets out what an operating agreement may and may not do, including provisions it cannot eliminate, such as the duty of loyalty and care and the obligation of good faith and fair dealing. Within those limits, the terms worth settling are which decisions need unanimity and which need a majority, whether either owner can force a capital call, how compensation and distributions are set, what production or schedule commitments each owner has, and what mechanism breaks a tie.
Common deadlock mechanisms include a neutral third party with a casting vote, mediation followed by binding arbitration, and a buy-sell trigger where one owner names a price and the other chooses whether to buy or sell at it. Any of them beats litigation between two dentists who share a waiting room.
Funding the obligation
A buy-sell agreement that obliges the surviving owner to purchase a deceased owner’s interest for a substantial sum, with no insurance behind it, is a promise to a grieving family that the practice may not be able to keep.
Life insurance is the standard answer for death. Disability buyout coverage addresses the harder case, since disability is more likely than death during a working career and the definitions in the policy need to match the trigger in the agreement. Review both when the practice value changes materially, because a policy sized to a valuation from eight years ago funds an obligation that no longer exists.
What I see most often
In the dental and orthodontic practices I have worked with, the buy-in gets papered and the buyout does not. The parties negotiate the entry price closely, then accept a short operating agreement whose exit provisions were never really read, because at that moment everyone is optimistic and nobody wants to negotiate their own departure. Years later the exit provisions are the only ones that matter, and they turn out to say that value will be agreed by the parties. The hour spent on the exit terms during the buy-in is worth more than every hour spent on the entry price.
Frequently Asked Questions
What should a dental practice partnership agreement include?
Decision thresholds, compensation and distribution rules, capital call obligations, buy-sell triggers, a stated valuation method with a tie-breaker, payment terms, funding, restrictions after exit, and a deadlock mechanism.
How is a buy-in price determined?
Usually by a valuation, discounted or adjusted by agreement. The more important question is what method applies to the later buyout, because that one gets applied when the parties are no longer cooperating.
Can I stop a departing co-owner from opening nearby?
Only through the sale-of-business exception. Utah Code 34-51-202(1)(b) preserves a covenant where the restricted individual receives value related to the sale, so structuring the exit as a purchase of the interest with the covenant tied to it is the workable path.
Should a dental partnership be a general partnership?
Rarely. Utah Code 16-18-306 makes general partners jointly and severally liable for partnership obligations. A limited liability company generally offers a better structure for a multi-owner practice.
What happens if a co-owner loses their license?
The agreement should say. In a professional corporation, Utah Code 16-11-13 imposes a default 90-day buyback at reasonable fair value if the governing documents are silent, which may not be the outcome anyone would have chosen.
How do we break a tie between two equal owners?
By agreeing on a mechanism in advance. Options include a neutral tie-breaker, mediation then arbitration, or a buy-sell provision where one owner sets a price and the other decides whether to buy or sell at it.
Do we need insurance to back the buy-sell agreement?
If the obligation is meaningful, yes. Life insurance covers death and disability buyout coverage addresses disability, and both should be reviewed when the practice value changes.
Bringing in a partner, or holding an operating agreement whose exit terms nobody has read? That is a short review with long consequences.
Schedule a consultation or call (801) 613-1472.
This article is general information, not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Statutes change, and the provisions described here were current as of November 2026.