associate dentist employment agreement

Associate Dentist Employment Agreements: The Clauses Owners Get Wrong

An associate dentist employment agreement in Utah now does less than it used to. The non-compete that used to anchor the document is void, so the clauses that actually protect a practice are the compensation formula, the notice period, the records provisions, and the nonsolicitation terms that survived.

Last updated: November 2026

Key Takeaways

  • Any non-compete entered into with a dentist on or after May 6, 2026 is void. Templates written before that date are actively dangerous, because suing on one exposes the practice to the associate’s fees and damages.
  • Nonsolicitation of staff, nondisclosure, and confidentiality obligations all survive and are expressly carved out of the non-compete definition.
  • A nonsolicitation clause may not stop a departing dentist from telling patients where they are going.
  • The compensation formula is where most associate disputes actually originate, and the fix is a worked example attached to the agreement.
  • Dental hygienists and dental assistants are not covered by the healthcare worker ban, so the analysis for them is different.

What changed, and why old templates are now a liability

House Bill 270 of the 2026 General Session rewrote Utah’s Post-Employment Restrictions Act. Utah Code 34-51-201(1)(b) provides that on or after May 6, 2026 a person and a healthcare worker may not enter into a healthcare non-compete agreement, and subsection (1)(c) makes an agreement that violates it void.

Section 34-51-102(5)(a)(xii) lists a dentist among the covered healthcare workers. The definition of a healthcare non-compete agreement in Section 34-51-102(4) reaches any agreement barring the worker, after they stop working for you, from providing a service they may provide under the scope of their license, either for a period of time or within a geographic area.

The reason a stale template is worse than no template is Section 34-51-301. If an employer seeks to enforce a covenant through arbitration or a civil action and it is determined to be unenforceable, the employer is liable for the employee’s arbitration costs, attorney fees and court costs, and actual damages.

What still works in an associate dentist employment agreement

Clause Status in Utah Practical note
Non-compete Void for dentists Remove it. Keeping it invites a fee-shifting claim.
Patient nonsolicitation Limited Cannot stop the dentist from telling patients where they are going.
Staff nonsolicitation Enforceable Expressly outside the non-compete definition.
Confidentiality and nondisclosure Enforceable Also expressly carved out. Protect fee schedules, patient lists, systems.
Notice period for resignation Enforceable Often the most practically useful protection left.
Compensation formula Enforceable The most litigated term. Define every deduction.
Records and property return Enforceable Covers charts, images, devices, credentials.
Lab and supply cost sharing Enforceable Must be spelled out or it becomes a dispute at the first big case.

The compensation formula deserves a worked example

Most associate disputes are not about the percentage. They are about what the percentage is applied to.

A formula of “30 percent of adjusted production” raises four questions the agreement should answer explicitly: adjusted by what, whether it is production or collections, what is deducted before the percentage applies, and who bears write-offs and insurance adjustments the associate did not negotiate.

The clauses that avoid the argument:

  • State whether compensation is on production or collections, and define the term.
  • List every deduction taken before the calculation, including lab, specific supplies, and any allocation of overhead.
  • Say who absorbs contractual write-offs, courtesy adjustments, and uncollectible accounts.
  • State the pay period and the timing, consistent with Utah’s wage payment requirements in Utah Code 34-28-5.
  • Address what happens to collections received after the associate leaves on work they performed.
  • Attach a sample calculation using real numbers. One page prevents most of these disputes.

Guaranteed minimums deserve their own attention. If a guarantee is recoverable against future production, say so, and say what happens to an unrecovered balance if employment ends.

Clinical autonomy and the practice’s own exposure

An associate agreement should say who decides clinical matters, and the answer should be the treating dentist.

This is not only good practice. Utah Code 58-69-804(2) bars a licensee from permitting an unlicensed person to direct, participate in, or interfere in the licensee’s practice of dentistry, and Section 58-69-501 now treats directing or interfering with a dentist’s judgment as unlawful conduct.

Production targets tied to specific procedures, or bonus structures that reward case acceptance rates, sit uncomfortably close to that line. A production expectation stated as a schedule and availability commitment is on much safer ground than one stated as a dollar target for a particular treatment category.

Malpractice coverage and tail

Say who carries professional liability coverage, at what limits, whether it is claims-made or occurrence, and who pays for tail coverage when the relationship ends.

A claims-made policy with no tail leaves the associate exposed for treatment already rendered, and leaves the practice arguing about it after the associate has left. It is a two-sentence provision that avoids a genuinely expensive problem.

Hygienists and assistants are a different analysis

The healthcare worker list in Section 34-51-102(5)(a) runs through more than thirty licensed occupations, including registered nurses, licensed practical nurses, physicians, physician assistants, optometrists, and mental health professionals. Dental hygienists and dental assistants are not on it.

That means the healthcare non-compete ban does not reach them, and agreements with them are analyzed under the general rule, including the one-year limit on post-employment restrictions in Section 34-51-201(1)(a). Whether such a covenant is worth having with a hygienist is a separate business question, and often the answer is no.

The exception nobody expects

Section 34-51-102(5)(b) excludes from the definition of healthcare worker an individual who holds a covered license but “whose employment or contractual agreement does not require or involve practicing under the scope of the individual’s license.”

So a dentist hired into a purely administrative or executive role that does not involve practicing dentistry is outside the ban. That is a narrow carve-out, and it should not be used as a workaround by labeling a clinical role administratively. The test is what the agreement requires the person to do.

Specialty notes

Orthodontics. An associate who takes over cases in progress needs a clear provision on responsibility for treatment started by someone else, and on compensation for visits on prepaid cases where no new revenue arrives.

Pediatric dentistry. Where public payers are significant, the agreement should address credentialing, who bears the cost and delay, and what happens if enrollment is not complete on the start date.

Periodontics and oral surgery. Anesthesia and analgesia permits are issued to the individual under Utah Code 58-69-301, so the agreement should state who holds which permit and what happens if one lapses.

What I see most often

In the associate agreements I have reviewed, the document is usually a form that came from another practice, and the two provisions that matter most are the two that were never customized. The compensation formula uses a term like adjusted production without defining it, and the restrictive covenant was copied from a version drafted before Utah changed the law. The first produces an argument in month four. The second produces an unenforceable clause that, if anyone ever tries to enforce it, shifts fees to the other side. Both are fixed in a single revision.

Common mistakes

  • Reusing a pre-2026 template with a non-compete still in it.
  • Leaving “adjusted production” undefined.
  • No sample compensation calculation.
  • Silence on collections received after the associate leaves.
  • No notice period, so the practice learns of a departure with two weeks of scheduled patients booked.
  • Nothing about tail coverage.
  • A patient nonsolicitation clause drafted more broadly than Section 34-51-203 permits.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can an associate dentist employment agreement still include a non-compete in Utah?

No. Utah Code 34-51-201(1)(b) makes a healthcare non-compete agreement entered into on or after May 6, 2026 void, and dentists are covered healthcare workers under Section 34-51-102(5)(a)(xii).

What can I use instead of a non-compete?

Staff nonsolicitation, confidentiality and nondisclosure obligations, a meaningful notice period, and compensation structures that make staying worthwhile. All of those survive the 2026 amendments.

Can I stop a departing associate from contacting patients?

Only partially. Utah Code 34-51-203 voids any nonsolicitation term that prevents a healthcare worker from telling a patient their current or future place of employment.

What happens if I try to enforce an old non-compete?

Utah Code 34-51-301 makes an employer that seeks enforcement and loses liable for the employee’s arbitration costs, attorney fees and court costs, and actual damages. Enforcing a void covenant is worse than doing nothing.

Does the ban apply to my hygienists?

No. Dental hygienists and dental assistants are not on the healthcare worker list in Section 34-51-102(5)(a), so agreements with them fall under the general rules, including the one-year limit.

Should the associate be paid on production or collections?

Either can work, but the agreement must define the term and list every deduction applied before the percentage. Attach a worked example using actual practice numbers.

Who pays for tail coverage when an associate leaves?

Whatever the agreement says. If it says nothing, the question surfaces after the associate has gone, which is the worst time to negotiate it.

Still using an associate template written before May 2026? That is the one document worth replacing this month.

Schedule a consultation or call (801) 613-1472.

Written by Jeremy Eveland, a Utah business attorney who represents dental and orthodontic practice owners in transactions, employment agreements, leases, entity structure, and succession planning. Related reading: dental practice lawyer in Utah and business lawyer.

This article is general information, not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Statutes change, and the provisions described here were current as of November 2026.

This entry was posted in Dental Law on by .

About Jeremy Eveland

Jeremy Eveland is a Utah business attorney and estate planning lawyer with offices in West Jordan and Lindon. He holds a Juris Doctor (JD) and an MBA, and is licensed to practice in Utah, Nevada, California, and Texas. He is not admitted to practice in other jurisdictions.