Category Archives: Dental Law

Business law for the owners and operators of dental, orthodontic, periodontal, and pediatric dental practices in Utah.

dental practice succession planning

Dental Practice Succession Planning: What Happens If You Cannot Work Tomorrow

Dental practice succession planning answers one question: what happens to the practice if you cannot work tomorrow. For most owners the practice is the largest asset they hold and the one that loses value fastest when the owner is suddenly absent.

Last updated: November 2026

Key Takeaways

  • A dental practice is a licensed business. Your spouse or personal representative may inherit the value but cannot practice dentistry, which is the problem a succession plan solves.
  • Disability is the more likely event during a working career and the one most plans ignore.
  • Name in advance who runs the practice, who can sign, and who is authorized to sell it, and give that person the documents to act.
  • Fund the buy-sell agreement. An unfunded purchase obligation is a promise the survivors may not be able to keep.
  • Since May 2026 you cannot retain associates with a non-compete, so a succession plan that assumes the clinical team stays needs a different retention mechanism.

The licensing problem at the center of it

Most business succession planning assumes the heirs can run the business. Dentistry does not allow that assumption.

Utah Code 58-69-804 permits a dentist to practice through a range of entity forms and does not restrict who may own them, which is genuinely helpful here: a surviving spouse can hold the equity in an LLC or a business corporation while a licensed dentist provides the clinical care.

Two constraints still apply. Subsection (2) provides that a licensee may not permit an unlicensed person to direct, participate in, or interfere in the practice of dentistry, and Section 58-69-501 treats such interference as unlawful conduct. So an inheriting family member can own, but cannot run the clinical side.

If the practice is a professional corporation the picture is harder. Section 16-11-7 limits who may hold shares and voids non-conforming issuances, and Section 16-11-13 imposes a default obligation to buy out a disqualified shareholder within 90 days at reasonable fair value. That default may not be what anyone would have chosen, and it is a reason to review the entity form as part of succession planning rather than treating it as settled.

Why value evaporates so quickly

A practice without its owner starts losing value immediately, and understanding the mechanism explains what the plan has to prevent.

  • Production stops on the day the owner does, while payroll, rent, and the loan continue.
  • Staff begin looking for work as soon as the future is uncertain, and a trained team is slow to rebuild.
  • Patients transfer to other practices, and the ones who leave first are typically the ones with treatment planned.
  • The buyer pool narrows to whoever can close quickly, which is not the buyer who pays the most.
  • Nobody has authority to act, so decisions wait while the value falls.

Every item on that list is addressed by naming people and giving them documents in advance.

What dental practice succession planning actually consists of

Element What it does Where it lives
Emergency operating authority Someone can sign checks and make payroll from day one Entity documents and banking authorizations
A named covering dentist Patients keep being treated while decisions are made A standing arrangement, ideally written
Authority to sell Someone is empowered to run a sale process Operating agreement, power of attorney, trust
Buy-sell agreement Sets who buys, at what price, on what terms A standalone agreement or the operating agreement
Funding Makes the buyout obligation payable Life and disability buyout insurance
Valuation method Prevents a fight at the worst time The buy-sell agreement
Records plan Meets retention and access obligations A written policy plus the transaction documents
Estate documents Directs the value to the right people Will, trust, and beneficiary designations

Disability is the case dental practice succession planning usually skips

Dental practice succession planning conversations gravitate to death, but disability is more likely during a career and considerably harder to handle.

Death is binary and triggers insurance and estate documents. Disability is ambiguous. Is it temporary? Will they return? At what point does a temporary arrangement become a sale? The practice needs to keep running throughout, and the person deciding may be the disabled owner’s spouse.

The plan should define disability with the same precision the insurance policy uses, so the buy-sell trigger and the policy definition do not diverge. It should say who decides and how, whether there is a waiting period before the buyout obligation arises, and what happens to compensation during it. And it should be checked against your disability buyout policy rather than drafted in isolation.

The three exit paths

Sell to an associate or partner. Usually the cleanest, because the clinical relationship already exists and patients stay. It requires a documented path, a valuation method, and financing that works for someone earlier in their career. A staged buy-in over several years is the common structure.

Sell to an outside buyer or a platform. The widest market, and the most dependent on the practice being transferable: a lease that can be assigned, clean entity records, documented systems, and production that does not rest entirely on you.

Wind down. Sometimes the right answer for a small practice with no buyer, but it produces the least value and it carries obligations that do not end when the door closes, particularly around patient notice and records.

Retention without covenants

A succession plan that assumes the clinical team stays needs to say why they would.

Since Utah Code 34-51-201(1)(b) voided healthcare non-compete agreements entered into on or after May 6, 2026, and Section 34-51-102(5)(a)(xii) put dentists inside that definition, an associate is free to leave when the owner becomes ill. That is exactly the moment a practice can least afford it.

What remains available is a defined ownership path, compensation that reflects the market, and the sale-of-business exception in Section 34-51-202(1)(b), which preserves a covenant where the restricted individual receives value related to a sale. In other words, the associate who is buying in can be restrained. The associate who is only employed cannot.

Coordinating succession planning with your estate plan

A revocable trust drafted without reference to the practice usually does not handle it well. The trust may hold the interest, but a trustee who is not a dentist cannot run a dental practice, and the trust document may not grant the powers needed to operate or sell a business quickly.

The pieces that need to be consistent are the entity’s transfer restrictions, the buy-sell agreement, the trust or will, and the beneficiary designations on any insurance funding the buyout. It is common to find a buy-sell agreement that says one thing and a trust that says another, and the conflict surfaces at the worst moment. Coordinate this with your estate planning and with business succession law rather than treating them as separate projects.

What to do this quarter

  1. Write down who runs the practice on day one if you cannot, and confirm they can access accounts and make payroll.
  2. Identify a covering dentist and have the conversation before you need it.
  3. Read your buy-sell agreement, if one exists, and check that it names a valuation method and a tie-breaker.
  4. Confirm the insurance funding matches the current value of the practice.
  5. Check that your trust or will actually reaches the practice interest and grants the powers to act on it.
  6. Review the entity form, particularly if the practice is a professional corporation.
  7. Put a records plan in writing.

What I see most often

In the dental and orthodontic practices I have worked with, succession planning is treated as retirement planning and therefore postponed, because retirement is years away. The plan that is missing is not the retirement plan. It is the plan for the Monday after something unexpected, and its absence is what turns a valuable practice into a distressed sale. The whole thing is a short set of documents and one conversation with a covering dentist, and the owners who have done it describe it as the least expensive protection they bought.

Frequently Asked Questions

What happens to my dental practice if I die?

Without a plan, it depends on your estate documents and who is willing to act. Utah permits non-dentists to own the entity, so family can inherit the value, but only a licensed dentist can provide the clinical care.

Can my spouse inherit my dental practice in Utah?

They can inherit the ownership interest in an LLC or business corporation, because Utah Code 58-69-804 does not restrict ownership. They cannot direct clinical practice, and a professional corporation raises additional restrictions under Title 16 Chapter 11.

What is a buy-sell agreement?

An agreement setting who buys an owner’s interest on death, disability, retirement, or withdrawal, at what price, on what terms. It should name a valuation method and a tie-breaker rather than leaving value to be agreed later.

Why does disability matter more than death in succession planning?

It is more likely during a working career and far more ambiguous. The plan has to define disability, say who decides, and set what happens during an uncertain period while the practice keeps operating.

Can I keep my associates from leaving if I become ill?

Not by covenant. Utah voided healthcare non-competes entered into on or after May 6, 2026. What remains is compensation, a defined ownership path, and the sale-of-business exception for an associate who is buying in.

Does my revocable trust cover my dental practice?

Only if it was drafted with the practice in mind. The trust needs to hold or reach the interest and grant powers to operate or sell a licensed business, and it needs to be consistent with the entity documents and any buy-sell agreement.

When should I start dental practice succession planning?

Now, regardless of age. The plan that matters most is the one for an unexpected absence, and it is a short set of documents that only works if it exists before it is needed.

No written answer to what happens if you cannot work next month? That is the gap worth closing first, and it is a short conversation.

Schedule a consultation or call (801) 613-1472.

Written by Jeremy Eveland, a Utah business attorney who represents dental and orthodontic practice owners in transactions, employment agreements, leases, entity structure, and succession planning. Related reading: dental practice lawyer in Utah, partner buy-ins and buy-sell agreements, and selling a dental practice in Utah.

This article is general information, not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Statutes change, and the provisions described here were current as of November 2026.

asset protection for dentists

Asset Protection for Utah Dentists: Keeping the Practice Separate From Everything Else

Asset protection for dentists is mostly separation and insurance, done early. No structure protects a clinician from a claim about their own treatment, but the practice, the building, and personal assets can be kept from being one pool that a single problem reaches.

Last updated: November 2026

Key Takeaways

  • An entity does not shield you from your own clinical negligence. It shields you from the business’s contractual and commercial liabilities.
  • Professional liability insurance is the primary protection for clinical risk. Structure is the secondary layer, and it addresses a different set of risks.
  • Utah gives a member’s judgment creditor a charging order against distributions rather than the company’s assets, which is the core of why the LLC matters here.
  • Personal guarantees defeat the structure by contract. They are the most common reason a well-formed entity does not help.
  • Timing is everything. Transfers made once a claim is on the horizon are attackable, which is why this work belongs in a quiet year.

Start by naming the risks separately

Asset protection for dentists gets discussed as one topic, but it is four different risks with four different answers.

Risk Primary protection What structure adds
Your own clinical negligence Professional liability insurance Very little. No entity blocks a claim against your own treatment
An associate’s or employee’s act Insurance, plus the practice entity Keeps the claim at the practice rather than reaching you personally
Business and contract liabilities The entity Lease, loans, vendor obligations stay with the company unless guaranteed
Premises and general liability General liability insurance, plus separating the real property Keeps a property claim away from the operating practice, and the reverse

Being clear about which risk you are addressing prevents the most common error in this area, which is buying structure to solve a problem that only insurance solves.

What the entity actually does

Utah Code 16-20-304 provides that a debt, obligation, or other liability of a limited liability company is solely that of the company, and that a member or manager is not personally liable for it solely by reason of being a member or manager. Subsection (1)(c) applies that even after dissolution, and subsection (2) provides that failure to observe formalities relating to the exercise of the company’s powers or management of its activities is not a ground for imposing liability.

That last provision is unusually helpful. In many states, informality is the argument a creditor uses to pierce the entity. Utah removed formalities from that analysis by statute.

What it did not remove is the effect of commingling, of a personal guarantee, or of your own conduct. An entity that pays personal expenses directly and keeps no separate accounts is presenting a creditor with a different argument, and a dentist who personally treated the patient is liable for that treatment regardless of the entity.

The charging order

The provision that makes the LLC structurally useful in asset protection for dentists is Utah Code 16-20-503.

On application by a judgment creditor of a member, a court may enter a charging order against the transferable interest of the judgment debtor for the unsatisfied amount of the judgment. That order constitutes a lien on the debtor’s transferable interest and, once the company is served, requires the company to pay over to the creditor any distribution that would otherwise go to the debtor.

The distinction that matters is what the creditor gets. A charging order reaches distributions, not the company’s assets and not management rights. A creditor holding a charging order against your interest in the entity that owns your office building does not thereby own the building.

The statute goes further in later subsections, addressing what a court may do where distributions will not satisfy the judgment, so this is not an impenetrable wall. It is a materially better position than owning the asset outright in your own name.

Separate the practice from the real property

This is the highest-value structural step available to most practice owners, and it is straightforward.

The practice is an operating business with employees, clinical activity, and payer contracts. The building is a long-lived asset with a mortgage. Held in one entity, a claim against either reaches both. Held separately, with a real written lease between them, they are two assets with two risk profiles.

The separation only works if it is respected. Separate bank accounts, a written lease at a defensible rent, rent actually paid, and separate records. A structure on paper that is ignored in practice is the version that fails.

The guarantee problem

Most practice owners have signed at least one personal guarantee, usually for the lease and the practice loan, sometimes for equipment financing.

A guarantee is a separate contract in which you promise to pay if the entity does not, and no entity statute affects it. This is the single most common reason a properly formed structure produces less protection than the owner expects.

What to do about it:

  • Track every guarantee you have signed, with amounts and expiry.
  • Negotiate caps and burn-offs at signing rather than accepting open-ended exposure.
  • Ask for release on an approved assignment, so a guarantee does not follow you after you sell.
  • Revisit older guarantees at renewal, when your payment history is leverage.

Insurance is the first layer, not the afterthought

For clinical risk, insurance is the protection and structure is the supplement. That means the policy details deserve as much attention as any entity chart.

  • Limits appropriate to your procedure mix, not to what you bought when you opened.
  • Whether the policy is claims-made or occurrence, and what tail coverage would cost.
  • Whether associates are covered under the practice policy or carry their own.
  • General liability and property coverage for the premises.
  • Employment practices coverage, which addresses a category the practice entity does not.
  • Cyber and breach response coverage, given the notification obligations a practice carries.
  • Umbrella coverage above the primary layers.

Timing, and the limit of all of this

Transfers made to put assets out of reach of a creditor who is already on the horizon are subject to challenge. The law of voidable transactions exists precisely for that situation, and a transfer made after a claim arises invites scrutiny of both the transfer and the person who made it.

The practical rule is simple. This planning belongs in a year when nothing is happening. Structure created while a dispute is pending is worth much less than the same structure created three years earlier, and it can make the underlying situation worse.

The honest limit is worth stating plainly as well. No structure available to a dentist prevents a claim about their own clinical work from being brought or from reaching them. Anyone offering a structure that promises otherwise is describing something other than Utah law.

Coordinate with the rest of the plan

Asset protection overlaps with estate planning and with succession, and doing any of the three in isolation tends to undo part of another.

Trust ownership of a practice interest, for instance, needs to work with the entity’s governing documents and with the licensing rules. It is generally workable with an LLC. It is a harder fit with a professional corporation, where Utah Code 16-11-7 restricts who may hold shares and makes non-conforming issuances void.

A practical sequence

  1. Review insurance first, including limits, tail, and the coverages you do not have.
  2. Confirm the practice is in an entity, and that the entity is respected in daily operation.
  3. Move the real property into its own entity, with a written lease.
  4. Inventory personal guarantees and negotiate at the next renewal.
  5. Coordinate the ownership structure with your estate plan and buy-sell agreement.
  6. Revisit after any material change: a new location, a new partner, a building purchase, a large loan.

What I see most often

In the dental and orthodontic practices I have worked with, the structure is usually half-built. There is an entity for the practice, the building is either in the same entity or in the owner’s own name, and there are three personal guarantees nobody has looked at since signing. The owner believes they are protected because an entity exists. The gap between that belief and the actual position is almost always the guarantees and the real property, and both are fixable in an ordinary year, which is the only year in which fixing them is worth much.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does an LLC protect a dentist from a malpractice claim?

No. An entity shields owners from the business’s debts and obligations, not from a claim based on the owner’s own clinical treatment. Professional liability insurance is the protection for that risk.

What does the entity actually protect against?

The practice’s contractual and commercial liabilities, and generally claims arising from employees’ acts. Utah Code 16-20-304 makes those the company’s liabilities rather than the owner’s.

What is a charging order?

Under Utah Code 16-20-503, it is the remedy a judgment creditor of a member gets against that member’s interest. It reaches distributions the company would have paid the debtor, rather than the company’s assets.

Should my building be in a separate entity?

Usually yes. Separating the real property from the operating practice, with a written lease between them, keeps a claim against one from automatically reaching the other.

Do personal guarantees undo my asset protection?

To the extent of the guarantee, yes. A guarantee is a separate contract and no entity statute affects it, which makes tracking and negotiating guarantees a central part of this work.

Can I set up protection after a claim arises?

It is far less effective and it invites challenge. Transfers made with a creditor on the horizon are subject to voidable transaction analysis, so this planning belongs in a quiet year.

Does Utah require me to observe corporate formalities to keep the shield?

Utah Code 16-20-304(2) provides that failure to observe formalities is not a ground for imposing liability on a member or manager. Commingling funds and personal guarantees remain separate problems.

Not sure what your current structure actually protects? A review in a quiet year is worth considerably more than the same conversation during a dispute.

Schedule a consultation or call (801) 613-1472.

Written by Jeremy Eveland, a Utah business attorney who represents dental and orthodontic practice owners in transactions, employment agreements, leases, entity structure, and succession planning. Related reading: dental practice lawyer in Utah, buying the building for your practice, and estate planning.

This article is general information, not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Statutes change, and the provisions described here were current as of November 2026.

dental records retention

Dental Records in Utah: How Long to Keep Them, Who Owns Them, What Happens at a Sale

Dental records retention in Utah is governed by more than one clock. The privacy rules set a six-year documentation requirement, the malpractice statute of limitations sets a practical floor for clinical charts, and the licensing division’s administrative rule sets the professional standard.

Last updated: November 2026

Key Takeaways

  • Retention is not one rule. Privacy documentation, clinical charts, employment records, and business records all run on different clocks.
  • HIPAA requires required documentation to be retained six years from creation or from when it was last in effect, whichever is later. That covers policies and related paperwork, not the clinical chart itself.
  • Utah’s malpractice limitations period runs two years from discovery and not more than four years from the act, which sets a practical floor for keeping the chart that would defend you.
  • The clinical retention period itself comes from the licensing division’s administrative rule, and that rule should be confirmed against its current text rather than from memory.
  • Selling or closing a practice does not end the obligation. Custody, retention, and later access all belong in the transaction documents.

Dental records retention runs on four different clocks

Category What it covers What sets the period
Privacy documentation Policies, notices, authorizations, related records Six years under 45 CFR 164.530(j)(2)
Clinical records Charts, radiographs, treatment notes, models The licensing division’s administrative rule, plus practical exposure
Defensive retention Whatever would prove what you did The malpractice limitations period in Utah Code 78B-3-404
Employment and business Payroll, wage, safety, tax, entity records Separate federal and state requirements

Owners looking at dental records retention tend to want a single number. There is not one, and the longest applicable period controls in practice, because destroying a record early is a problem no matter which rule required keeping it.

The privacy documentation clock

The requirement here is precise and easy to comply with once you know it. 45 CFR 164.530(j)(2) provides that a covered entity must retain the documentation required by the section for six years from the date of its creation or the date when it last was in effect, whichever is later.

Read the second half of that sentence carefully. A privacy policy adopted in 2018 and replaced in 2025 was last in effect in 2025, so the six years runs from then, not from adoption. The same logic applies to notices of privacy practices and to any policy that stayed in force for years.

This requirement applies to the documentation the rules require, which is not the same thing as the clinical chart. Both need retaining. They just get there by different routes.

The defensive clock

The strongest practical reason to keep a chart is that it is the evidence in any claim about the treatment.

Utah Code 78B-3-404(1) provides that a malpractice action against a health care provider shall be commenced within two years after the plaintiff or patient discovers, or through reasonable diligence should have discovered, the injury, whichever first occurs, but not to exceed four years after the date of the alleged act, omission, neglect, or occurrence.

Section 78B-3-403 defines health care provider to include a dentist and a dental hygienist, so the period applies directly.

Two exceptions in Section 78B-3-404(2) run on their own one-year discovery clocks: an allegation that a foreign object was wrongfully left in a patient’s body, and an allegation that the provider fraudulently concealed the misconduct. Both are reasons that a chart discarded on the earliest permissible date can turn out to have been discarded too early.

Claims involving patients who were minors at the time of treatment raise additional timing questions that deserve specific advice rather than a general rule, and pediatric practices should get that advice before setting a destruction schedule.

What the clinical retention period is, and where to find it

The professional standard for how long a dentist keeps patient records in Utah is set by the licensing division’s administrative rule for the Dentist and Dental Hygienist Practice Act rather than by the statute itself. Utah Code 58-69-502 makes falsely making an entry in, or altering, a medical record with intent to conceal a wrongful or negligent act unprofessional conduct, which tells you the records themselves are treated as significant, but the chapter does not itself state a retention period.

This article deliberately does not quote a number for that rule. Administrative rules are amended more often than statutes, and a retention period repeated from memory or from an out-of-date source is exactly the kind of detail that causes a practice to destroy something it should have kept. Confirm the current rule text before you set a destruction schedule, and write the date of that confirmation into your policy.

What counts as a record for dental records retention

A dental record is more than the progress notes, and a retention policy that covers only the chart leaves gaps.

  • Clinical notes and treatment plans.
  • Radiographs and photographs, including originals rather than only compressed copies.
  • Models, scans, and digital impression files.
  • Informed consent documents.
  • Correspondence and referral letters.
  • Prescription records.
  • Financial and billing records associated with treatment.
  • Communications with patients, including text and email where clinically relevant.

Digital formats create their own problem. A record you retained but can no longer open because the practice management software was replaced is not much better than one you destroyed. Migration planning is part of retention.

Ownership and access

The physical or electronic record is generally the practice’s property. The information in it belongs, in a practical sense, to the patient, who has rights of access under the privacy rules.

Two consequences follow for owners. A patient request for records is not a negotiation, and it is not conditioned on the account being paid. And a records request from a lawyer, an insurer, or a board should be routed to counsel before anything is produced, because what is produced and how it is produced can matter later.

Selling, buying, or closing a practice

Records outlive transactions, which is why they need a real section in the transaction documents rather than a single sentence.

On a sale, the agreement should say who holds the records, for how long, what notice patients receive, how the seller obtains access if a claim or an inquiry arrives later, and what happens if the buyer subsequently sells or closes.

On a closure, the practice needs a plan for notifying patients, for making records available, and for retaining or transferring them for the balance of the applicable period. Closing a practice without a records plan converts a retirement into an open obligation with nobody assigned to it.

A workable dental records retention policy

  1. Confirm the current administrative rule period and write the confirmation date in the policy.
  2. Set your retention period at the longest applicable clock rather than the shortest.
  3. Define what counts as the record, including images and digital files.
  4. Address format migration so retained records stay readable.
  5. Set a destruction method that protects the information, and document each destruction.
  6. Suspend destruction immediately when a claim, a board inquiry, or a subpoena appears.
  7. Review the policy annually alongside your privacy documentation.

That sixth item is the one that most often fails. A routine destruction schedule that continues to run after a claim arrives is a considerably larger problem than the underlying claim.

What I see most often

In the dental practices I have worked with, records retention is handled by habit rather than by policy, and the habit is usually to keep everything forever in a storage unit or an old server nobody maintains. That is not the worst outcome, but it creates its own exposure: unreadable formats, unsecured old media, and no record of what exists. The more damaging version is the opposite, where a practice adopts a destruction schedule based on a number someone remembered, and applies it to charts that were still needed. Both are solved by the same short document, written once and reviewed annually.

Frequently Asked Questions

How long must a Utah dental practice keep patient records?

There is no single number. The clinical period comes from the licensing division’s administrative rule, HIPAA requires six years for required documentation, and Utah’s malpractice limitations period sets a practical floor. Confirm the current rule text before setting a schedule.

What is the HIPAA retention requirement?

Under 45 CFR 164.530(j)(2), required documentation must be retained six years from the date of creation or the date it was last in effect, whichever is later. That covers policies and related paperwork rather than the clinical chart.

How long can a patient sue over dental treatment in Utah?

Utah Code 78B-3-404 requires a malpractice action to be commenced within two years after discovery of the injury and not more than four years after the act. Separate one-year discovery rules apply to foreign objects and to fraudulent concealment.

Do radiographs and digital files count as records?

Yes. A retention policy should cover images, scans, models, consent forms, correspondence, and clinically relevant communications, not only the progress notes.

Can I withhold records from a patient who owes money?

No. A patient’s right of access under the privacy rules is not conditioned on payment, and treating a records request as leverage creates a separate problem.

What happens to records when I sell my practice?

Whatever the purchase agreement says, which is why it needs a real records section covering custody, retention, patient notice, and the seller’s later access if a claim or board inquiry arrives.

When should I stop destroying records?

Immediately when a claim, a board inquiry, or a subpoena appears. A routine destruction schedule that keeps running after notice is a much larger problem than the underlying matter.

Setting a retention schedule, closing a practice, or facing a records request you are unsure about? Get it right before anything is destroyed or produced.

Schedule a consultation or call (801) 613-1472.

Written by Jeremy Eveland, a Utah business attorney who represents dental and orthodontic practice owners in transactions, employment agreements, leases, entity structure, and succession planning. Related reading: dental practice lawyer in Utah, HIPAA compliance for dental offices, and dental practice purchase agreements.

This article is general information, not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Statutes and administrative rules change, and the provisions described here were current as of November 2026.

osha compliance

OSHA and Infection Control in a Utah Dental Office: The Owner’s Obligations

OSHA compliance in a dental office is enforced in Utah by the state program, not the federal agency. The standards that matter most to a practice are bloodborne pathogens, hazard communication, and the general duty to provide a workplace free from recognized hazards.

Last updated: November 2026

Key Takeaways

  • Utah runs its own occupational safety and health program under Title 34A Chapter 6, administered through the Utah Labor Commission.
  • Utah Code 34A-6-201 imposes both a general duty to furnish employment free from recognized hazards and a duty to comply with the promulgated standards.
  • The bloodborne pathogens standard is the center of dental office compliance: an exposure control plan, engineering controls, training, hepatitis B vaccination offers, and a sharps injury log.
  • Hazard communication reaches every chemical in the office, including sterilants, developer, and materials most staff never think of as hazardous.
  • The written plan has to describe your actual office. A generic binder is worse than none, because it documents a program you are not running.

Who enforces OSHA compliance in Utah

Utah operates its own occupational safety and health program. Utah Code 34A-6-201 sets out the core duties.

“Each employer shall: (a) furnish to each of its employees employment and a place of employment that are free from recognized hazards that are causing or are likely to cause death or serious physical harm to its employees; and (b) comply with occupational safety and health standards promulgated under this chapter.”

Utah Code 34A-6-201(1)

That first clause is the general duty, and it reaches hazards no specific standard addresses. The second clause incorporates the standards themselves, which the division issues under Section 34A-6-202 and which include adopted federal standards.

The practical consequence for a dental practice is that the federal standards are the substance and the Utah Occupational Safety and Health division is the enforcer. An inspection is a state inspection.

Bloodborne pathogens is the center of it

The bloodborne pathogens standard at 29 CFR 1910.1030 was written for exactly this kind of workplace, and OSHA maintains a topic page on it. For a dental office the recurring elements are:

  • A written exposure control plan, reviewed and updated at least annually and whenever tasks or procedures change.
  • Documented consideration of safer devices. The plan must reflect that you evaluated engineering controls, and the evaluation should involve the people who use them.
  • Engineering and work practice controls, including sharps containers, safer needle devices, and a no-recapping practice.
  • Personal protective equipment provided at no cost to the employee, with the employer responsible for cleaning and replacement.
  • Hepatitis B vaccination offered to employees with occupational exposure within the required timeframe, at no cost, with a signed declination if refused.
  • Post-exposure evaluation and follow-up, with a plan you can execute the evening a staff member is stuck.
  • Training at hire and annually, documented.
  • A sharps injury log, maintained so as to protect the confidentiality of the injured employee.

The declination form and the vaccination offer are among the most commonly missing items in small practices, usually because a long-tenured employee was hired before anyone was tracking it.

Hazard communication

The hazard communication standard at 29 CFR 1910.1200 applies to chemicals in the workplace, and a dental office has more of them than owners tend to picture.

Sterilants and high-level disinfectants, surface disinfectants, ultrasonic cleaning solutions, etchants, bonding agents, monomers, developer and fixer where film is still used, nitrous oxide, oxygen, compressed gases, and general cleaning chemicals all sit inside the standard.

What it requires is a written hazard communication program, a maintained inventory, safety data sheets accessible to employees during every shift, correct labeling on secondary containers, and training that covers the specific hazards present in your office rather than a generic overview.

Secondary container labeling is the most common finding. A spray bottle filled from a bulk container and labeled in marker with an abbreviation is not compliant, and it is the kind of thing that is visible from the doorway.

Other OSHA compliance requirements that reach a dental office

Area What a dental practice needs
Emergency action and exits Unobstructed, marked exit routes and a plan staff have actually been told about
Fire extinguishers Appropriate type, accessible, inspected, and training if employees are expected to use them
Electrical safety No permanent reliance on extension cords, covered panels, accessible disconnects
Compressed gases Cylinders secured upright, stored properly, valve protection in place
Radiation Equipment registration and shielding requirements, which sit alongside rather than inside the OSHA standards
Recordkeeping Injury and illness records where required by size and industry classification
Employee rights posting The required workplace poster displayed where employees can see it

What triggers an inspection

Small dental offices are rarely selected at random. The realistic triggers are an employee complaint, a serious injury, or a referral from another agency.

The employee complaint is the most common, and it is worth understanding that the complaint does not have to be about the hazard that ends up being cited. An inspection prompted by one issue can result in citations for what is visible during the visit, which is why the labeling and exit obstruction items matter out of proportion to their apparent seriousness.

Retaliation against an employee who raises a safety concern is separately prohibited, and it converts a manageable compliance question into a much more serious one.

The OSHA compliance binder problem

Most dental practices own an OSHA compliance binder. Many of those binders were purchased once, contain a template exposure control plan naming a person who left years ago, and describe procedures the office does not follow.

That is worse than having nothing, because the standards require a plan specific to your workplace and reviewed annually. A generic document that contradicts your actual practice is evidence that the program is not being run.

The fix is not expensive. Read the plan, correct the names and the procedures so they describe this office, document the annual review, and keep the training records where you can find them.

Specialty notes

Orthodontics. Lower exposure risk than surgical practices, but the same bloodborne pathogens obligations apply, and larger teams make training documentation harder to keep current.

Pediatric dentistry. Nitrous oxide use raises waste gas scavenging and monitoring questions, and the general duty clause reaches them even where no single standard is cited.

Periodontics and oral surgery. Higher sharps volume, more compressed gases, and sedation equipment mean this is the setting where the exposure control plan and post-exposure procedures get tested in reality.

What I see most often

In the dental practices I have worked with, the clinical infection control is genuinely good and the paperwork behind it is stale. The office sterilizes correctly, uses safer sharps, and has a well-trained team, and the written exposure control plan still names a former employee as the responsible person and has not been reviewed in four years. Nothing about that reflects an unsafe office. It reflects a documentation gap, and documentation is what an inspection looks at.

Frequently Asked Questions

Who enforces OSHA compliance in a Utah dental office?

Utah operates its own program under Title 34A Chapter 6, administered through the Utah Labor Commission. An inspection of a Utah dental practice is a state inspection applying the adopted standards.

What is the most important OSHA standard for a dental practice?

The bloodborne pathogens standard at 29 CFR 1910.1030. It requires a written exposure control plan, engineering controls, personal protective equipment, hepatitis B vaccination offers, post-exposure procedures, annual training, and a sharps injury log.

How often must the exposure control plan be updated?

At least annually, and whenever new tasks or procedures affect occupational exposure. The review itself should be documented, because an undocumented review is difficult to demonstrate later.

Does hazard communication apply to a dental office?

Yes. Sterilants, disinfectants, etchants, bonding agents, compressed gases, and general cleaning chemicals are all covered, and secondary container labeling is one of the most common findings.

Do I have to pay for employees’ personal protective equipment?

Yes. Under the bloodborne pathogens standard, required personal protective equipment is provided at no cost to the employee, and the employer is responsible for cleaning, repair, and replacement.

What triggers an inspection of a small dental office?

Usually an employee complaint, a serious injury, or a referral from another agency. Citations are not limited to the subject of the complaint, which is why visible items matter.

Is a purchased compliance binder enough?

No. The standards require a plan specific to your workplace, reviewed annually. A generic binder that names people who no longer work there documents that the program is not being run.

Not sure whether your written plans match how the office actually runs? That gap is inexpensive to close and expensive to leave.

Schedule a consultation or call (801) 613-1472.

Written by Jeremy Eveland, a Utah business attorney who represents dental and orthodontic practice owners in transactions, employment agreements, leases, entity structure, and succession planning. Related reading: dental practice lawyer in Utah and HIPAA compliance for dental offices.

This article is general information, not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Regulations change, and the provisions described here were current as of November 2026.

hipaa compliance for dental offices

HIPAA Compliance for Dental Offices: What the Owner Is On the Hook For

HIPAA compliance for dental offices is an owner obligation, not an IT project. The privacy and security rules require documented policies, a real risk analysis, business associate agreements, and a breach response you can execute inside sixty calendar days.

Last updated: November 2026

Key Takeaways

  • Individual breach notice is due without unreasonable delay and in no case later than 60 calendar days after discovery.
  • A breach involving 500 or more individuals must be reported to the Secretary contemporaneously with the individual notice. Smaller breaches go in a log reported within 60 days after the calendar year ends.
  • Media notice has a different trigger: more than 500 residents of a single state or jurisdiction, not 500 individuals overall.
  • Required documentation must be retained for six years from creation or from when it was last in effect, whichever is later.
  • Most dental office breaches are not sophisticated attacks. They are lost laptops, misdirected records, and vendors who were never put under a business associate agreement.

What HIPAA compliance for dental offices actually requires

HIPAA compliance for dental offices is governed by rules that sit in 45 CFR Part 164, and for a dental practice they come down to a manageable list.

  • A designated privacy official and a security official. In a small practice this is often the same person, and it can be the owner, but it has to be someone.
  • Written policies and procedures that describe what your office actually does, not a binder purchased and never opened.
  • A security risk analysis covering electronic protected health information, revisited when something changes.
  • Workforce training, documented, including for temporary staff.
  • Business associate agreements with every vendor that touches protected health information.
  • A notice of privacy practices provided to patients.
  • A breach response process you could actually run on the day you need it.

The documentation requirement has a specific duration. Section 164.530(j)(2) requires that a covered entity retain the required documentation for six years from the date of its creation or the date when it last was in effect, whichever is later.

The breach notification clock

This is the part worth knowing before you need it, because the deadlines run from discovery and not from when you finish investigating.

Who is notified Trigger Deadline
Affected individuals Any breach of unsecured protected health information Without unreasonable delay, and in no case later than 60 calendar days after discovery
Prominent media outlets Breach involving more than 500 residents of a state or jurisdiction Same outer limit of 60 calendar days after discovery
The Secretary of HHS Breach involving 500 or more individuals Contemporaneously with the individual notice
The Secretary of HHS Breach involving fewer than 500 individuals Log it, and report not later than 60 days after the end of the calendar year

Two details in that table are commonly conflated. The media notification standard in 45 CFR 164.406(a) speaks of more than 500 residents of a state or jurisdiction. The reporting standard to the Secretary in Section 164.408(b) speaks of 500 or more individuals. Those are different tests, and a multi-state breach can satisfy one and not the other.

The individual notice deadline is in Section 164.404(b), and the phrase that matters is “without unreasonable delay.” Sixty days is the outer limit, not the target. A practice that sits on a known breach for fifty-nine days has not complied merely by filing on day sixty.

Business associate agreements are where small practices are exposed

A business associate is a vendor that creates, receives, maintains, or transmits protected health information on your behalf. In a dental office that list is longer than owners expect.

  • Practice management and electronic health record software vendors.
  • Cloud backup and hosting providers.
  • Outsourced billing and revenue cycle companies.
  • Information technology contractors with access to your systems.
  • Document shredding and record storage companies.
  • Transcription services.
  • Some marketing and patient communication platforms, including automated reminder and review request tools.
  • Answering services that take clinical messages.

The last two are the ones most often missed, because they arrive as a marketing purchase rather than a clinical one. A patient communication platform that sends appointment reminders is handling protected health information.

A signed agreement is not the whole obligation, but its absence is an easy finding for anyone reviewing your compliance, and it is entirely preventable.

Where HIPAA compliance for dental offices actually breaks down

The incidents that generate notification obligations in small practices are rarely sophisticated.

  • A laptop or portable drive with unencrypted patient data, lost or stolen.
  • A misdirected email or fax containing patient information.
  • Records released to the wrong person, often a parent without custody or an ex-spouse.
  • A former employee whose system access was never disabled.
  • Ransomware arriving through a phishing email opened at the front desk.
  • A practice management vendor’s own breach, which is still your notification obligation to your patients.
  • Old records left in a space during a move or a closure.
  • Discussing a patient in a reception area within earshot of others.

Encryption is the single highest-value control on that list, because the notification rules apply to unsecured protected health information. Properly encrypted data that is lost is a materially different problem from unencrypted data that is lost.

Online reviews and patient communication

This deserves its own warning, because it is the one that catches otherwise careful owners.

Responding publicly to a negative online review by discussing the patient’s treatment, their attendance, or even confirming they are a patient discloses protected health information. The impulse to correct the record is understandable and the exposure is real.

The safe response acknowledges the review generically, invites the person to contact the office directly, and says nothing that confirms or describes any treatment relationship. Train whoever manages your online presence on this specifically, including any outside marketing vendor, and remember that the vendor’s mistake is still your disclosure.

Practice transitions and records

Selling, buying, or closing a practice all involve moving protected health information, and the transaction documents should say how.

A purchase agreement should address custody of records after closing, retention obligations, notice to patients about the transition, and continued access for the seller if a claim or inquiry arrives later. A practice closure requires a plan for notifying patients and for retaining or transferring records rather than simply locking a door.

A HIPAA compliance checklist for dental offices that are behind

  1. Name your privacy official and security official in writing.
  2. Complete a security risk analysis and write down what it found.
  3. Inventory every vendor that touches patient information and get business associate agreements signed.
  4. Confirm encryption on laptops, portable drives, and backups.
  5. Write a one-page breach response procedure with the 60-day clock on it and a named decision maker.
  6. Train the team and document that you did.
  7. Set a calendar reminder to review all of it annually.

What I see most often

In the dental practices I have worked with, the compliance binder exists and the business associate agreements do not. The binder was purchased years ago, the policies describe a practice that does not resemble this one, and nobody has looked at it since. Meanwhile the practice has added a cloud backup service, an automated reminder platform, and an outside billing company, none of which is under an agreement. That gap is inexpensive to close and is the first thing anyone reviewing the practice will ask about.

Frequently Asked Questions

How long do I have to notify patients of a breach?

Without unreasonable delay and in no case later than 60 calendar days after discovery, under 45 CFR 164.404(b). Sixty days is the outer limit rather than the target.

When do I have to report a breach to HHS?

For a breach involving 500 or more individuals, contemporaneously with the individual notice under 45 CFR 164.408(b). For fewer than 500 individuals, maintain a log and report not later than 60 days after the end of the calendar year.

When is media notification required?

Under 45 CFR 164.406(a), when a breach involves more than 500 residents of a single state or jurisdiction. Note that this is a different test from the 500-or-more-individuals threshold for reporting to the Secretary.

How long must HIPAA documentation be retained?

Six years from the date of creation or the date it was last in effect, whichever is later, under 45 CFR 164.530(j)(2). That is separate from any clinical record retention requirement.

Do I need a business associate agreement with my software vendor?

If the vendor creates, receives, maintains, or transmits protected health information on your behalf, yes. That commonly includes practice management software, cloud backup, outsourced billing, IT contractors, and patient communication platforms.

Can I respond to a negative online review?

Only generically. Confirming that the reviewer is a patient, or discussing their treatment or attendance, discloses protected health information. Acknowledge the review and invite direct contact instead.

Is encryption required?

The rules address it as an addressable specification rather than an absolute mandate, but the practical effect is significant, because the breach notification obligations apply to unsecured protected health information.

Not sure whether your vendor agreements and breach procedure would hold up? That review is short, and it is much cheaper before an incident.

Schedule a consultation or call (801) 613-1472.

Written by Jeremy Eveland, a Utah business attorney who represents dental and orthodontic practice owners in transactions, employment agreements, leases, entity structure, and succession planning. Related reading: dental practice lawyer in Utah and dental practice purchase agreements.

This article is general information, not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Regulations change, and the provisions described here were current as of November 2026.

dental office building

Buying the Building for Your Dental Practice: Separate Entity, Lease-Back, and Financing

Buying a dental office building solves the problem the lease creates: you stop being a tenant who can be relocated, repriced, or blocked from assigning. It also creates a new problem, because the practice and the property are now two businesses that should not sit in the same entity.

Last updated: November 2026

Key Takeaways

  • Hold the real property in a separate entity from the practice and lease it to the practice. Two assets, two risk profiles, two eventual buyers.
  • Write a real lease between the two entities. A related-party lease with no document is the version that causes trouble at sale, at audit, and at divorce.
  • Utah’s LLC statute makes the company’s debts the company’s own and does not condition that on observing formalities, but commingling still undermines the separation you formed the entity to create.
  • A personal guarantee on the mortgage reaches past both entities, so negotiate its scope the same way you would a lease guarantee.
  • Owning the building changes your exit. You can sell the practice and keep the building, which is often the better retirement structure.

Why the two-entity structure is the default

The practice is an operating business with employees, clinical risk, payer contracts, and a licensed owner. The building is a long-lived asset with a mortgage and a tenant. They have different risk profiles, different buyers, and different time horizons.

Holding them separately does several things at once:

  • A claim against the practice does not automatically reach the real property.
  • The practice pays deductible rent, and the property entity has rental income against which its own expenses run.
  • You can sell the practice and keep the building, or sell them to different buyers at different times.
  • The building can pass to family members who are not dentists, without touching an entity that must comply with the Dental Practice Act.
  • A future practice buyer has a clear lease to evaluate, rather than a purchase price that mixes an operating business with real estate.

The last point matters more than owners expect. A buyer financing a practice purchase is underwriting a different asset from a buyer financing commercial property, and mixing them narrows the pool for both.

Which entity holds the dental office building

A limited liability company is the usual answer. Utah Code 16-20-304 provides that a debt, obligation, or other liability of a limited liability company is solely that of the company, that a member or manager is not personally liable solely by reason of being one, and that failure to observe formalities relating to the exercise of the company’s powers is not a ground for imposing liability.

Utah also gives a judgment creditor of a member a specific and limited remedy. Under Section 16-20-503, a court may enter a charging order against the transferable interest of a judgment debtor, which constitutes a lien and requires the company to pay over distributions that would otherwise go to the debtor. That is a meaningfully different position from a creditor seizing the asset itself.

Note what the practice entity cannot be for this purpose. If the practice is a professional corporation, Utah Code 16-11-7 restricts who may hold shares. A property entity holding real estate has no reason to carry that restriction, which is another argument for keeping the two apart.

The lease between your two entities is a real document

This is the step most owners skip, on the theory that they are both sides of the transaction so the paperwork is a formality. It is not.

A written lease at a defensible rent does several jobs. It supports the rent deduction on one side and the rental income treatment on the other. It gives a future practice buyer a document to evaluate and assume. It preserves the separation between the entities if a creditor ever argues the two are really one. And it settles who pays for the roof, the parking lot, the HVAC, and the operatory plumbing before those questions arise.

Terms worth getting right:

  • A rent figure supported by market data, documented at the time it is set.
  • A term and renewal options long enough that a practice buyer can finance against them.
  • Clear allocation of maintenance, taxes, insurance, and capital repairs.
  • An assignment provision that permits transfer to a qualified practice buyer, since the point of owning the building is not to block your own sale.
  • What happens if you sell the building but not the practice, or the practice but not the building.

Tax treatment of related-party rent and of rental activity has its own rules, including the passive activity provisions at 26 U.S.C. 469. Set the structure with your accountant rather than assuming rent is simply a deduction.

Financing

Owner-occupied commercial real estate is financed differently from investment property, and dental practices are a well-understood category for lenders.

Conventional commercial mortgages, and SBA 504 loans, which exist specifically for owner-occupied real estate and equipment, are the common routes. What matters legally is less which product you choose than what the loan documents require of you.

Read the guarantee, the covenants, and the transfer restrictions. A loan that prohibits transferring the property or changing the entity’s ownership without lender consent constrains your estate planning and your exit. That is negotiable at origination and awkward afterward.

Buying the dental office building you already lease

Sometimes the opportunity is the dental office building you already occupy. Two provisions in your existing lease may matter more than the asking price.

A right of first refusal gives you the chance to match a third party’s offer. A purchase option gives you the right to buy on stated terms. If your lease has either, read the mechanics carefully, because both are usually time-limited and easy to lose by inaction.

If your lease has neither, that is worth adding at the next renewal. It costs a landlord little and it can be worth a great deal.

Due diligence on the dental office building itself

  • Title, including easements, access rights, and any restrictive covenants.
  • Survey, and whether the parking count satisfies both the zoning requirement and your actual patient flow.
  • Zoning and permitted use, confirmed for a dental clinic rather than assumed from general commercial zoning.
  • Environmental assessment, especially for older buildings and any prior use involving chemicals.
  • Building systems capacity for operatory plumbing, vacuum, compressed air, and electrical load.
  • Existing tenants and their leases, if you are buying more space than you occupy.
  • Any owners association, which brings its own assessments, restrictions, and lien rights.

How it changes your exit

Owning the building gives you a retirement structure that a tenant does not have. You can sell the practice to a younger dentist and keep the building, becoming their landlord, which converts your largest business asset into income without requiring you to keep working.

That structure has to be built deliberately. The lease to the practice needs a term and rent that a buyer will accept, the assignment provisions have to permit the transfer, and your estate planning documents need to reflect two assets rather than one. Done well, it is one of the better outcomes available to a practice owner. Done as an afterthought, it produces a building nobody wants and a practice nobody can finance.

What I see most often

In the matters I have handled, the owner buys the building and puts it in the same entity as the practice, because that was the entity that already existed and the closing was moving quickly. Everything works until the practice is sold, at which point the buyer wants the practice and not the real estate, and the structure has to be unwound under time pressure and with tax consequences that a little planning would have avoided. The second recurring version is the two-entity structure with no lease between them, which is fine right up to the first audit, the first creditor, or the first buyer who asks to see the lease.

Frequently Asked Questions

Should I buy the building my dental practice occupies?

It depends on your timeline and capital, but it removes the assignment, relocation, and renewal risks a lease creates, and it gives you an exit in which you sell the practice and keep the property.

Should the building be in the same entity as the practice?

No. Hold the real property in a separate limited liability company and lease it to the practice. That separates two different risk profiles and lets the two assets be sold separately.

Do I need a written lease between my own two entities?

Yes. It supports the tax treatment on both sides, preserves the separation between the entities, and gives a future practice buyer a document to evaluate and assume.

What rent should the practice pay the property entity?

A market-supported figure, documented when it is set. Related-party rent has its own tax considerations, so set the number with your accountant rather than picking one that is convenient.

Does a separate entity protect the building from a practice claim?

It is the structure that makes that argument available. Utah Code 16-20-304 makes a company’s liabilities its own, and Section 16-20-503 limits a member’s judgment creditor to a charging order against distributions.

Will I still have to sign personally for the mortgage?

Usually. A personal guarantee is a separate contract and the entity does not affect it, so negotiate its scope, any cap, and any release the same way you would a lease guarantee.

Can I keep the building when I sell the practice?

Yes, and that is often the point. It requires a lease the buyer can accept and assignment terms that permit the transfer, which is why the two-entity structure should be set up before a sale is in view.

Buying a building, or holding one in the same entity as the practice? Both are worth a conversation before the next closing or the next sale.

Schedule a consultation or call (801) 613-1472.

Written by Jeremy Eveland, a Utah business attorney who represents dental and orthodontic practice owners in transactions, employment agreements, leases, entity structure, and succession planning. Related reading: dental practice lawyer in Utah, dental office lease negotiation, and real estate law.

This article is general information, not legal or tax advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Statutes change, and the provisions described here were current as of November 2026.

dental office lease

Dental Office Lease Negotiation: The Clauses That Cost Dentists the Most

A dental office lease is usually the largest contract a practice owner ever signs, larger in total dollars than the practice loan. It is also the document most likely to reduce what the practice is worth, because the clause that governs your exit was written by the landlord.

Last updated: November 2026

Key Takeaways

  • The assignment clause decides whether you can sell your practice. Read it before anything else, including the rent.
  • Remaining term and renewal options set a ceiling on what a buyer can borrow, which sets a ceiling on what a buyer can pay.
  • Leasehold improvements in a dental suite are expensive and immovable, which is exactly why the lease should say who owns them and what happens at the end of the term.
  • A relocation clause lets a landlord move a fully plumbed operatory suite. In dentistry that is not a minor inconvenience.
  • Personal guarantees survive the entity. Negotiate a burn-off or a cap rather than accepting an open-ended one.

Read the assignment clause first

Every dental office lease negotiation should start at the back of the document, where assignment and subletting live.

The range of what you will find:

  • Absolute discretion. The landlord may withhold consent for any reason or no reason. This makes the landlord a party to your eventual sale, with leverage.
  • Not to be unreasonably withheld. Better, and worth insisting on, though reasonable is a word people litigate.
  • Consent with conditions. Consent is available but the landlord may charge a fee, require a new guarantee, or reset rent to market.
  • Permitted transfers. The version you want, which carves out a sale of the practice to a qualified dentist and a transfer to an entity you control.

Also check whether the clause covers a change of control. If the lease is held by your LLC and the clause treats a transfer of membership interests as an assignment, then selling the entity triggers the same consent requirement as selling the assets.

The negotiating position is straightforward and usually persuasive: a dental practice is a long-term, high-improvement, low-turnover tenancy, and a landlord who blocks a sale to a qualified dentist ends up with an empty built-out suite instead of a paying tenant.

Term, options, and financeability

A buyer’s lender will size financing against the time remaining on the lease. A practice with three years left and no options is harder to finance than the same practice with three years plus two five-year options, which means it is worth less.

Negotiate options early rather than at renewal. An option to extend, exercisable by notice within a defined window, costs the landlord little at signing and is expensive to obtain later when your alternative is to move a fully plumbed suite.

Watch the notice mechanics on options. A window that opens twelve months before expiration and closes nine months before is easy to miss, and missing it can convert a valuable option into a holdover negotiation.

The clauses that matter most in a dental office lease

Clause Why it matters to a dental practice What to ask for
Assignment and change of control Controls whether you can sell Permitted transfer to a licensed dentist buyer, consent not unreasonably withheld
Term and options Drives financeability and value Options that outlast a buyer’s likely loan term
Relocation Landlord can move you Delete it, or exclude tenants with plumbed operatories
Exclusive use Keeps a competing practice out of the building An exclusive for general dentistry or your specialty
Leasehold improvements Large cost, immovable Clarity on ownership, and no obligation to restore to shell
Restoration and surrender Can be a six-figure exit cost Remove or narrow the obligation to remove improvements
Building systems Operatories need water, air, vacuum, power Landlord responsibility for base building systems and capacity
Operating expenses Pass-throughs can outgrow rent Caps on controllable expenses, audit rights, exclusions
Personal guarantee Survives your entity Burn-off after a period of good payment, or a capped guarantee
Holdover Penalty rent during a transition Reduce the multiplier and add a short grace period

Restoration is the sleeper clause

Most tenants read the improvement allowance and skip the surrender obligation. In dentistry those two clauses are connected.

A dental buildout involves plumbing to each operatory, dedicated electrical, vacuum and compressed air lines, lead shielding, cabinetry, and specialized flooring. A surrender clause requiring the premises be returned in the condition received, ordinary wear and tear excepted, can be read to require removing all of it.

Negotiate specificity. The best outcome is that improvements become the landlord’s property at expiration and no removal is required. The workable outcome is a schedule attached to the lease listing exactly what must be removed, agreed at signing rather than argued about at the end of a fifteen-year tenancy.

Personal guarantees

Landlords ask for them routinely, and the entity does not help. A guarantee is a separate contract in which you promise to pay if the entity does not, and Utah’s limited liability protections in Utah Code 16-20-304 do not reach a debt you personally agreed to.

Three ways to make one acceptable. Cap it at a defined dollar amount rather than the full remaining rent. Add a burn-off so the guarantee ends after a set period of timely payment. And limit its duration so it does not follow you after an approved assignment, which otherwise means you can sell the practice and still guarantee the buyer’s rent.

If you are buying a practice

Ask for the complete lease with every amendment on day one, not during diligence. The lease can change the deal, and it is better to know before the letter of intent is signed.

Then make landlord consent a condition of closing, on terms acceptable to you rather than merely obtained. A consent that arrives with a rent increase and a fresh personal guarantee is technically consent and practically a repricing of the transaction.

Specialty notes

Orthodontics. Open-bay layouts and larger square footage make relocation and restoration clauses more consequential, and signage and visibility terms carry more weight because of the referral-driven and consumer-facing nature of the practice.

Pediatric dentistry. Parking, stroller access, and waiting area size matter more than in a general practice, and those are lease terms rather than design preferences.

Periodontics and oral surgery. Higher electrical and mechanical loads, gas storage, and recovery space mean the base building capacity representations are worth negotiating rather than assuming.

What I see most often

In the dental office lease matters I have handled, the lease is produced late, read quickly, and signed under a construction deadline. Two clauses account for most of the later regret. The assignment clause is accepted as written, and turns up years later as the reason a sale is delayed or repriced while the landlord considers consent. And the surrender clause is skimmed, then read carefully for the first time at the end of the term, when the estimate for removing the buildout arrives. Both are ordinary points to negotiate at signing and nearly impossible to fix afterward.

Common mistakes

  • Negotiating rent and free rent while accepting the assignment clause as boilerplate.
  • Signing a lease whose term is shorter than the practice loan.
  • Leaving a relocation clause in a lease for a plumbed operatory suite.
  • Accepting an open-ended personal guarantee with no cap and no burn-off.
  • Missing the notice window to exercise an option.
  • No cap or audit right on operating expense pass-throughs.
  • Assuming the landlord will be reasonable at sale time because they have been reasonable so far.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the most important clause in a dental office lease?

The assignment clause. It determines whether you can sell your practice without the landlord’s permission and what that permission will cost, which makes it the clause that most affects the value of the business.

How long should a dental office lease be?

Long enough that a future buyer can finance a purchase against the remaining term, which usually means an initial term plus renewal options that extend well beyond a typical practice loan.

Who owns the leasehold improvements in a dental suite?

Whatever the lease says. Because a dental buildout is expensive and effectively immovable, ownership at expiration and any obligation to remove improvements should both be addressed explicitly.

Can my landlord relocate my dental practice?

If the lease contains a relocation clause, potentially yes. For a practice with plumbed operatories that is a serious exposure, and the clause should be deleted or narrowed to exclude your premises.

Do I have to sign a personal guarantee?

Landlords commonly require one. If you must give it, negotiate a dollar cap, a burn-off after a period of timely payment, and release on an approved assignment so it does not follow you after a sale.

What happens to my lease when I sell the practice?

It has to be assigned, which usually requires landlord consent. Make that consent a closing condition on acceptable terms, because consent granted with a rent increase and a new guarantee changes the economics.

Should I negotiate an exclusive use clause?

If the building could house a competing practice, yes. An exclusive for general dentistry or for your specialty prevents the landlord from placing a direct competitor in the same building.

Holding a lease renewal, a new lease, or an assignment request from a buyer? A lease review is short and it protects the largest number in the practice.

Schedule a consultation or call (801) 613-1472.

Written by Jeremy Eveland, a Utah business attorney who represents dental and orthodontic practice owners in transactions, employment agreements, leases, entity structure, and succession planning. Related reading: dental practice lawyer in Utah, buying a dental practice in Utah, and real estate law.

This article is general information, not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Statutes change, and the provisions described here were current as of November 2026.

dental office worker classification

Hygienists, Assistants and Associates: Employee or Independent Contractor?

Dental office worker classification is decided by law, not by the label on the agreement. In Utah an individual performing services for wages is presumed to be an employee, and the burden of showing otherwise sits with the practice.

Last updated: November 2026

Key Takeaways

  • Utah Code 35A-4-204(3) presumes employment. To rebut it, the practice must show both that the person is customarily engaged in an independently established business of the same nature, and that they are free from control over the means of performance.
  • Both parts must be satisfied. Meeting one is not enough, and a signed agreement calling someone a contractor does not establish either.
  • A hygienist working your schedule, in your operatory, on your patients, with your equipment and your instruments is very difficult to classify as a contractor.
  • Different agencies apply different tests, so the same worker can be a contractor for one purpose and an employee for another. The safest structure satisfies all of them.
  • Misclassification exposure is cumulative: unpaid payroll taxes, unemployment contributions, workers compensation, wage claims, and benefits.

The Utah test, quoted

Utah’s Employment Security Act supplies the test that most often decides these questions for a dental practice, and it starts from a presumption.

“Services performed by an individual for wages or under any contract of hire, written or oral, express or implied, are considered to be employment subject to this chapter, unless it is shown to the satisfaction of the division that: (a) the individual is customarily engaged in an independently established trade, occupation, profession, or business of the same nature as that involved in the contract of hire for services; and (b) the individual has been and will continue to be free from control or direction over the means of performance of those services, both under the individual’s contract of hire and in fact.”

Utah Code 35A-4-204(3)

Three features of that sentence matter for dental office worker classification.

The default is employment. The practice carries the burden. And the word “and” between the two conditions means both must be established, so a person who genuinely runs an independent business but works entirely under your direction still fails the test.

The final phrase carries as much weight as the rest of the sentence: free from control “both under the individual’s contract of hire and in fact.” A well-drafted agreement that describes independence, contradicted by how the work is actually done, does not help.

Applying it to the roles in a dental office

Role Typical classification Why
Dental assistant Employee Works your schedule, under supervision, with your equipment, on your patients
Front office and treatment coordinator Employee Same reasons, plus integration into practice operations
Staff hygienist Employee Set schedule, practice-owned instruments, practice-set fees, supervision requirements
Temporary hygienist from an agency Depends on the arrangement Often the agency’s employee. Read the agency contract rather than assuming
Associate dentist Usually employee, sometimes contractor Turns on control over schedule, fees, materials, and staff, not on the title
Visiting specialist who sets own terms Sometimes contractor Own instruments, own fees, own schedule, own patients, own business
Outside billing or IT vendor Contractor Independent business serving many practices

The hygienist row is the one that causes most of the trouble, because paying a hygienist as a contractor is a persistent piece of folklore in the profession. Under a test that asks about control over the means of performance and about an independently established business, a hygienist who works the days you assign, on the patients you schedule, with instruments you own and sterilize, at fees you set, is very hard to place outside employment.

Supervision requirements push in the same direction

Dentistry has a structural feature that other industries do not: the law requires supervision of certain work.

Utah Code 58-69-102 defines direct supervision as the supervising dentist being present and available for face-to-face communication when and where services are provided, and general supervision as the supervising dentist being available for consultation regarding work the dentist has authorized. Section 58-69-803 governs the use of dental assistants, and Section 58-69-801 sets dental hygienist practice standards.

A practice that must supervise a worker’s clinical output is asserting exactly the kind of direction that the classification test treats as evidence of employment. That does not make contractor status impossible for every clinical role, but it does mean the argument starts from behind.

Different agencies, different tests

Classification is not one question with one answer. It is several questions asked by different bodies, each with its own test, and the same facts can produce different results.

  • Federal tax. The IRS applies a common law analysis focused on behavioral control, financial control, and the relationship of the parties. Its guidance on independent contractor status is the starting point.
  • Utah unemployment insurance. The two-part test in Section 35A-4-204(3) quoted above.
  • Wage and hour. Federal wage law and Utah’s wage payment rules in Utah Code 34-28-5, which governs when wages must be paid.
  • Workers compensation. Administered through the Utah Labor Commission, with its own coverage analysis.

The practical consequence is that structuring a relationship to satisfy only the most permissive test is a poor strategy, because you do not get to choose which agency asks.

What misclassification actually costs

The exposure is not a single penalty. It accumulates across categories, and it usually surfaces through an unemployment claim filed by someone who thought they were an employee, or through an injury with no workers compensation coverage behind it.

  • Unpaid employer payroll taxes, plus the employee share that was never withheld, plus interest.
  • Unpaid unemployment insurance contributions.
  • Workers compensation exposure for an injury with no coverage.
  • Wage claims, including overtime for a worker who should have been non-exempt.
  • Benefits the worker would have received, where a plan is in place.

Note also Section 35A-4-204(4), which provides limited relief where an employer treated a person as independently established consistent with a prior formal determination by the division. That is a narrow safe harbor and not an argument available to a practice that simply assumed.

If you do use a contractor, document it properly

Some relationships are genuinely independent. Where that is true, the paperwork should reflect the reality rather than construct it.

  • A written agreement describing a defined scope rather than open-ended availability.
  • Evidence the person serves other practices and holds themselves out as a business.
  • Their own insurance, and their own instruments where practical.
  • Invoices, rather than a recurring fixed payment identical to a payroll run.
  • Genuine control by the contractor over how and when the work is performed.
  • No integration into your employee handbook, benefits, or performance review process.

If reading that list makes the relationship sound unworkable for the role you have in mind, that is the answer. The role is employment.

What I see most often

In the dental practices I have worked with, misclassification is almost never a scheme. It is an inherited habit, usually adopted because a colleague did it that way, and it persists because nothing goes wrong until something does. The trigger is almost always an unemployment claim or an injury, and by then the arrangement has been in place for years, which is what turns a small monthly saving into a large retroactive number. The fix is inexpensive if it happens before that, and it typically involves converting one or two roles and leaving the genuinely independent vendors alone.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I pay my dental hygienist as an independent contractor in Utah?

Usually not. Utah Code 35A-4-204(3) presumes employment unless the practice shows both an independently established business of the same nature and freedom from control over the means of performance. A hygienist on your schedule and equipment rarely meets both.

Does a signed independent contractor agreement settle the question?

No. The Utah test asks whether the person is free from control both under the contract and in fact. A document describing independence that is contradicted by daily practice does not establish classification.

Can an associate dentist be an independent contractor?

Sometimes, depending on the facts. The analysis turns on who controls the schedule, the fee schedule, the materials, and the staff, and on whether the dentist genuinely operates an independent practice, not on what the agreement is titled.

Which test applies to my dental office worker classification?

Several. Utah unemployment insurance applies the two-part test in Section 35A-4-204(3), the IRS applies a common law analysis, and wage and workers compensation questions have their own frameworks. A defensible structure satisfies all of them.

What triggers a misclassification review?

Most often an unemployment claim by a worker who believed they were an employee, or a workplace injury where no workers compensation coverage exists. Neither is something a practice controls.

What does misclassification cost?

Unpaid payroll and unemployment taxes with interest, workers compensation exposure, wage claims including overtime, and benefits the worker would have received. The amounts accumulate over the years the arrangement was in place.

Are temporary hygienists from an agency my employees?

Often the agency’s, but not always. Read the agency agreement, because it allocates responsibility for taxes, insurance, and workers compensation, and some arrangements leave more with the practice than owners expect.

Not sure whether a role in your office is classified correctly? That review is far cheaper before a claim than after one.

Schedule a consultation or call (801) 613-1472.

Written by Jeremy Eveland, a Utah business attorney who represents dental and orthodontic practice owners in transactions, employment agreements, leases, entity structure, and succession planning. Related reading: dental practice lawyer in Utah and associate dentist employment agreements.

This article is general information, not legal or tax advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Statutes change, and the provisions described here were current as of November 2026.

dentist non-compete

Are Non-Competes Enforceable Against Dentists in Utah?

A dentist non-compete in Utah is void if it was entered into on or after May 6, 2026. Dentists are named healthcare workers under the amended Post-Employment Restrictions Act, and the statute says an agreement violating the ban is void rather than merely unenforceable in part.

Last updated: November 2026

Key Takeaways

  • The ban applies to agreements entered into on or after May 6, 2026. The date the agreement was entered into is the operative fact.
  • Two exceptions survive: a reasonable severance agreement, and a covenant related to or arising out of the sale of a business where the restricted person receives value related to the sale.
  • A dentist whose role does not require practicing under the license is outside the definition, which is narrow and depends on what the agreement actually requires.
  • Nonsolicitation, nondisclosure, and confidentiality agreements are all expressly excluded from the definition of a non-compete agreement and remain available.
  • An employer that sues on an unenforceable covenant and loses pays the employee’s arbitration costs, attorney fees, court costs, and actual damages.

The statute, in the order it applies

Three sections do the work, and reading them in sequence is the fastest way to get to an answer.

First, the ban. Utah Code 34-51-201(1)(b) provides that on or after May 6, 2026, a person and a healthcare worker may not enter into a healthcare non-compete agreement. Subsection (1)(c) makes an agreement violating Subsection (1) void.

Second, the definitions. Section 34-51-102(5)(a) defines healthcare worker by listing licensed occupations, and subparagraph (xii) is “a dentist as that term is defined in Section 58-69-102.” Section 34-51-102(4) defines a healthcare non-compete agreement as one under which, after the worker no longer works for or with the person, the worker will not engage in a service they may provide under the scope of their license, either for a restricted period or within a specific geographic area.

Third, the exceptions. Section 34-51-202(1) preserves a reasonable severance agreement mutually and freely agreed upon in good faith at or after the time of termination, and a covenant related to or arising out of the sale of a business if the restricted individual receives value related to the sale.

Who is covered and who is not

Person Covered by the ban? Why
Associate dentist Yes Named in Section 34-51-102(5)(a)(xii)
Owner dentist selling the practice Covenant still enforceable Sale-of-business exception, because value is received
Departing co-owner bought out Generally enforceable if structured as a purchase Same exception, if the exit is a sale and value is received
Dentist in a purely administrative role No Section 34-51-102(5)(b) excludes work not requiring practice under the license
Dental hygienist No Not on the healthcare worker list
Dental assistant No Not on the healthcare worker list
Front office and administrative staff No Not licensed under a listed act

The list in Section 34-51-102(5)(a) runs through more than thirty occupations, including advanced practice registered nurses, licensed practical nurses, physicians, physician assistants, optometrists, podiatric physicians, psychologists, and a range of mental health and social work licenses. Dental auxiliaries are conspicuously absent from it.

Nonsolicitation is limited but not eliminated

Section 34-51-203, enacted by the same bill, provides that on or after May 6, 2026 a person and a healthcare worker may not enter into a nonsolicitation agreement that prevents the healthcare worker from informing a patient of their current place of employment or their future place of employment. An agreement violating that is void.

Read carefully, that provision targets one specific restraint. It does not abolish nonsolicitation agreements generally. Section 34-51-102(7)(b) separately excludes nonsolicitation agreements, nondisclosure agreements, and confidentiality agreements from the definition of a non-compete agreement altogether.

So a practice can still protect its staff from being recruited away and its confidential information from being used. What it cannot do is prevent a departing dentist from telling patients where they went.

The fee-shifting provision changes the risk calculation

Section 34-51-301 provides that if an employer seeks to enforce a non-compete agreement or a healthcare non-compete agreement through arbitration or by filing a civil action, and the agreement is determined to be unenforceable, the employer is liable for the employee’s costs associated with arbitration, attorney fees and court costs, and actual damages.

Before 2026, an overbroad covenant carried the risk of being narrowed or ignored. Now attempting to enforce a void covenant is an affirmative liability. A practice holding an unrevised template is not merely unprotected. It is holding an instrument that can cost money if anyone acts on it.

What a practice can actually do instead

The protection has to shift from restraint to structure, and the tools that remain are real.

  • Staff nonsolicitation. Enforceable and often more valuable than a patient restriction, because rebuilding a trained team is slower than replacing a producer.
  • Confidentiality and trade secret protection. Fee schedules, payer contracts, patient lists, and systems all qualify for protection if actually treated as confidential.
  • Notice periods. A meaningful notice obligation, with a real consequence for breach, buys time to schedule around a departure.
  • Compensation and ownership paths. The retention mechanism that survived is the one that always worked best anyway.
  • The sale structure. When an owner leaves, structuring the exit as a purchase of their interest with a covenant tied to the consideration puts the restriction inside the surviving exception.
  • Severance. Section 34-51-202(1)(a) preserves a covenant in a reasonable severance agreement agreed at or after termination, though it remains subject to common law requirements.

Agreements signed before May 6, 2026

The ban applies to agreements entered into on or after that date. An older agreement is analyzed under the law that applied when it was made, including the general one-year limit in Section 34-51-201(1)(a) and the common law requirements that have always applied to restrictive covenants.

That is not a reason to rely on an old covenant. Enforcement still turns on reasonableness in scope, duration, and geography, and Section 34-51-301 fee shifting applies to an unsuccessful enforcement attempt regardless. If a practice is considering acting on a pre-2026 covenant against a dentist, that is a conversation to have before filing anything.

What this means for practice value

A practice whose production depends heavily on associates now carries a risk that cannot be papered over. Buyers know it, and a well-advised buyer will ask about the production split during diligence.

The answer is not a covenant. It is a retention story: compensation that reflects the market, a defined path to ownership where that fits, and a working environment people do not want to leave. That has always been the durable version of retention. Utah has now made it the only one.

What I see most often

In the practices I have worked with, the associate agreement is the last document anyone thinks about and the first one that matters when someone resigns. Since the 2026 change, the recurring problem is not a badly drafted covenant. It is an unrevised one, still sitting in the file, giving an owner a false sense that departures are controlled. The conversation that follows a resignation is much better when the owner already knows the covenant is void than when they find out from the associate’s lawyer.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are non-competes enforceable against dentists in Utah?

Not in ordinary employment. Utah Code 34-51-201(1)(b) makes a healthcare non-compete agreement entered into with a dentist on or after May 6, 2026 void. The exceptions are a reasonable severance agreement and a covenant arising out of the sale of a business.

Does the ban apply to a non-compete I signed in 2023?

The ban applies to agreements entered into on or after May 6, 2026. An earlier agreement is analyzed under prior law, including the one-year limit and the common law reasonableness requirements.

Can a dental practice sale still include a non-compete?

Yes. Utah Code 34-51-202(1)(b) preserves a covenant related to or arising out of the sale of a business where the restricted individual receives value related to the sale.

Are dental hygienists covered by the ban?

No. The healthcare worker list in Section 34-51-102(5)(a) does not include dental hygienists or dental assistants, so covenants with them are analyzed under the general rules.

Can I stop a departing dentist from telling patients where they went?

No. Utah Code 34-51-203 voids a nonsolicitation agreement that prevents a healthcare worker from informing a patient of their current or future place of employment.

What happens if I sue on a void non-compete?

Under Section 34-51-301, if the agreement is determined unenforceable, the employer is liable for the employee’s arbitration costs, attorney fees and court costs, and actual damages.

Is a nondisclosure agreement still allowed with a dentist?

Yes. Nondisclosure, confidentiality, and nonsolicitation agreements are expressly excluded from the definition of a non-compete agreement in Section 34-51-102(7)(b).

Holding covenants you are not sure about, or facing a departure? Knowing which clauses still bind is worth an hour before anyone sends a letter.

Schedule a consultation or call (801) 613-1472.

Written by Jeremy Eveland, a Utah business attorney who represents dental and orthodontic practice owners in transactions, employment agreements, leases, entity structure, and succession planning. Related reading: dental practice lawyer in Utah, associate dentist employment agreements, and partner buy-ins and buy-sell agreements.

This article is general information, not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Statutes change, and the provisions described here were current as of November 2026.

associate dentist employment agreement

Associate Dentist Employment Agreements: The Clauses Owners Get Wrong

An associate dentist employment agreement in Utah now does less than it used to. The non-compete that used to anchor the document is void, so the clauses that actually protect a practice are the compensation formula, the notice period, the records provisions, and the nonsolicitation terms that survived.

Last updated: November 2026

Key Takeaways

  • Any non-compete entered into with a dentist on or after May 6, 2026 is void. Templates written before that date are actively dangerous, because suing on one exposes the practice to the associate’s fees and damages.
  • Nonsolicitation of staff, nondisclosure, and confidentiality obligations all survive and are expressly carved out of the non-compete definition.
  • A nonsolicitation clause may not stop a departing dentist from telling patients where they are going.
  • The compensation formula is where most associate disputes actually originate, and the fix is a worked example attached to the agreement.
  • Dental hygienists and dental assistants are not covered by the healthcare worker ban, so the analysis for them is different.

What changed, and why old templates are now a liability

House Bill 270 of the 2026 General Session rewrote Utah’s Post-Employment Restrictions Act. Utah Code 34-51-201(1)(b) provides that on or after May 6, 2026 a person and a healthcare worker may not enter into a healthcare non-compete agreement, and subsection (1)(c) makes an agreement that violates it void.

Section 34-51-102(5)(a)(xii) lists a dentist among the covered healthcare workers. The definition of a healthcare non-compete agreement in Section 34-51-102(4) reaches any agreement barring the worker, after they stop working for you, from providing a service they may provide under the scope of their license, either for a period of time or within a geographic area.

The reason a stale template is worse than no template is Section 34-51-301. If an employer seeks to enforce a covenant through arbitration or a civil action and it is determined to be unenforceable, the employer is liable for the employee’s arbitration costs, attorney fees and court costs, and actual damages.

What still works in an associate dentist employment agreement

Clause Status in Utah Practical note
Non-compete Void for dentists Remove it. Keeping it invites a fee-shifting claim.
Patient nonsolicitation Limited Cannot stop the dentist from telling patients where they are going.
Staff nonsolicitation Enforceable Expressly outside the non-compete definition.
Confidentiality and nondisclosure Enforceable Also expressly carved out. Protect fee schedules, patient lists, systems.
Notice period for resignation Enforceable Often the most practically useful protection left.
Compensation formula Enforceable The most litigated term. Define every deduction.
Records and property return Enforceable Covers charts, images, devices, credentials.
Lab and supply cost sharing Enforceable Must be spelled out or it becomes a dispute at the first big case.

The compensation formula deserves a worked example

Most associate disputes are not about the percentage. They are about what the percentage is applied to.

A formula of “30 percent of adjusted production” raises four questions the agreement should answer explicitly: adjusted by what, whether it is production or collections, what is deducted before the percentage applies, and who bears write-offs and insurance adjustments the associate did not negotiate.

The clauses that avoid the argument:

  • State whether compensation is on production or collections, and define the term.
  • List every deduction taken before the calculation, including lab, specific supplies, and any allocation of overhead.
  • Say who absorbs contractual write-offs, courtesy adjustments, and uncollectible accounts.
  • State the pay period and the timing, consistent with Utah’s wage payment requirements in Utah Code 34-28-5.
  • Address what happens to collections received after the associate leaves on work they performed.
  • Attach a sample calculation using real numbers. One page prevents most of these disputes.

Guaranteed minimums deserve their own attention. If a guarantee is recoverable against future production, say so, and say what happens to an unrecovered balance if employment ends.

Clinical autonomy and the practice’s own exposure

An associate agreement should say who decides clinical matters, and the answer should be the treating dentist.

This is not only good practice. Utah Code 58-69-804(2) bars a licensee from permitting an unlicensed person to direct, participate in, or interfere in the licensee’s practice of dentistry, and Section 58-69-501 now treats directing or interfering with a dentist’s judgment as unlawful conduct.

Production targets tied to specific procedures, or bonus structures that reward case acceptance rates, sit uncomfortably close to that line. A production expectation stated as a schedule and availability commitment is on much safer ground than one stated as a dollar target for a particular treatment category.

Malpractice coverage and tail

Say who carries professional liability coverage, at what limits, whether it is claims-made or occurrence, and who pays for tail coverage when the relationship ends.

A claims-made policy with no tail leaves the associate exposed for treatment already rendered, and leaves the practice arguing about it after the associate has left. It is a two-sentence provision that avoids a genuinely expensive problem.

Hygienists and assistants are a different analysis

The healthcare worker list in Section 34-51-102(5)(a) runs through more than thirty licensed occupations, including registered nurses, licensed practical nurses, physicians, physician assistants, optometrists, and mental health professionals. Dental hygienists and dental assistants are not on it.

That means the healthcare non-compete ban does not reach them, and agreements with them are analyzed under the general rule, including the one-year limit on post-employment restrictions in Section 34-51-201(1)(a). Whether such a covenant is worth having with a hygienist is a separate business question, and often the answer is no.

The exception nobody expects

Section 34-51-102(5)(b) excludes from the definition of healthcare worker an individual who holds a covered license but “whose employment or contractual agreement does not require or involve practicing under the scope of the individual’s license.”

So a dentist hired into a purely administrative or executive role that does not involve practicing dentistry is outside the ban. That is a narrow carve-out, and it should not be used as a workaround by labeling a clinical role administratively. The test is what the agreement requires the person to do.

Specialty notes

Orthodontics. An associate who takes over cases in progress needs a clear provision on responsibility for treatment started by someone else, and on compensation for visits on prepaid cases where no new revenue arrives.

Pediatric dentistry. Where public payers are significant, the agreement should address credentialing, who bears the cost and delay, and what happens if enrollment is not complete on the start date.

Periodontics and oral surgery. Anesthesia and analgesia permits are issued to the individual under Utah Code 58-69-301, so the agreement should state who holds which permit and what happens if one lapses.

What I see most often

In the associate agreements I have reviewed, the document is usually a form that came from another practice, and the two provisions that matter most are the two that were never customized. The compensation formula uses a term like adjusted production without defining it, and the restrictive covenant was copied from a version drafted before Utah changed the law. The first produces an argument in month four. The second produces an unenforceable clause that, if anyone ever tries to enforce it, shifts fees to the other side. Both are fixed in a single revision.

Common mistakes

  • Reusing a pre-2026 template with a non-compete still in it.
  • Leaving “adjusted production” undefined.
  • No sample compensation calculation.
  • Silence on collections received after the associate leaves.
  • No notice period, so the practice learns of a departure with two weeks of scheduled patients booked.
  • Nothing about tail coverage.
  • A patient nonsolicitation clause drafted more broadly than Section 34-51-203 permits.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can an associate dentist employment agreement still include a non-compete in Utah?

No. Utah Code 34-51-201(1)(b) makes a healthcare non-compete agreement entered into on or after May 6, 2026 void, and dentists are covered healthcare workers under Section 34-51-102(5)(a)(xii).

What can I use instead of a non-compete?

Staff nonsolicitation, confidentiality and nondisclosure obligations, a meaningful notice period, and compensation structures that make staying worthwhile. All of those survive the 2026 amendments.

Can I stop a departing associate from contacting patients?

Only partially. Utah Code 34-51-203 voids any nonsolicitation term that prevents a healthcare worker from telling a patient their current or future place of employment.

What happens if I try to enforce an old non-compete?

Utah Code 34-51-301 makes an employer that seeks enforcement and loses liable for the employee’s arbitration costs, attorney fees and court costs, and actual damages. Enforcing a void covenant is worse than doing nothing.

Does the ban apply to my hygienists?

No. Dental hygienists and dental assistants are not on the healthcare worker list in Section 34-51-102(5)(a), so agreements with them fall under the general rules, including the one-year limit.

Should the associate be paid on production or collections?

Either can work, but the agreement must define the term and list every deduction applied before the percentage. Attach a worked example using actual practice numbers.

Who pays for tail coverage when an associate leaves?

Whatever the agreement says. If it says nothing, the question surfaces after the associate has gone, which is the worst time to negotiate it.

Still using an associate template written before May 2026? That is the one document worth replacing this month.

Schedule a consultation or call (801) 613-1472.

Written by Jeremy Eveland, a Utah business attorney who represents dental and orthodontic practice owners in transactions, employment agreements, leases, entity structure, and succession planning. Related reading: dental practice lawyer in Utah and business lawyer.

This article is general information, not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Statutes change, and the provisions described here were current as of November 2026.